Tyler Callihan leaves Reds vs Braves game with left arm injury

Cincinnati rookie Tyler Callihan exits early after crashing into wall during defensive play against Braves.

Cincinnati Reds left fielder Tyler Callihan (32) leaves the game with an injury during the third inning against the Atlanta Braves at Truist Park in Atlanta, Georgia, on May 5, 2025. Photo by Brett Davis/Imagn Images

By Anna Fadiah and Hayu Andini

Cincinnati Reds rookie Tyler Callihan left Monday night’s game against the Atlanta Braves after injuring his left arm during a defensive effort that ended in a costly play. The incident occurred in the bottom of the third inning, when Callihan sprinted toward the left-field corner in pursuit of a slicing fly ball hit by Braves slugger Matt Olson.

As Callihan extended his glove in an attempt to make a difficult catch, he momentarily secured the ball. However, momentum carried him into the outfield wall, jarring the ball loose and resulting in an inside-the-park home run. Olson’s two-run play capped a four-run surge by Atlanta, who had already built a 2-0 lead after Austin Riley’s RBI single earlier in the inning.

Callihan remained on the ground in clear discomfort, clutching his left forearm as trainers rushed to his side. He was helped off the field moments later and did not return. The extent of Callihan’s injury remains uncertain, pending further evaluation by team medical staff.

Reds rookie injured during defensive effort

The 24-year-old outfielder, who was appearing in just his fourth major league game, had shown promise in the field despite limited opportunities at the plate. Entering Monday’s contest, Callihan had one hit and one RBI in six at-bats, giving him a .167 batting average. His only plate appearance in the game came earlier in the third inning, when he grounded out to first base.

Callihan, a native of Jacksonville, Florida, was selected by the Reds in the third round of the 2019 MLB Draft. Known for his athleticism and versatility, he has steadily risen through the Cincinnati farm system. His promotion to the major league roster was part of a broader effort by the Reds to inject youth and energy into their lineup during a stretch of injury-related roster moves and underwhelming offensive production.

Atlanta capitalizes on momentum after Callihan’s exit

Matt Olson’s inside-the-park homer not only extended the Braves’ lead but also marked a turning point in the game. The Braves capitalized on the momentum shift, taking advantage of the Reds’ shaken outfield and bullpen. Olson’s drive was the kind of aggressive baserunning play that exemplifies the Braves’ offensive mindset — putting pressure on the defense and forcing mistakes.

For Cincinnati, the loss of Callihan further complicates a season already marked by injuries and inconsistent performances. Manager David Bell and the Reds coaching staff now face the possibility of having to dig even deeper into their minor league depth chart, especially if Callihan’s injury proves to be significant.

What’s next for Tyler Callihan?

At this point, there is no official word from the Reds regarding the severity of Callihan’s injury or how much time he may miss. The team is expected to release an update following medical imaging and a full evaluation. Given the nature of the injury — a left forearm issue sustained during high-impact contact with a wall — it’s possible that Callihan could be sidelined for an extended period depending on whether there is any structural damage.

Losing a rookie with upside always stings, particularly when the player was just beginning to find his rhythm in the big leagues. For Callihan, who has already faced his share of adversity in the minors, including injuries and pandemic-related development delays, the latest setback is yet another hurdle on the path to establishing himself as a full-time major leaguer.

Reds’ injury concerns continue

Callihan’s injury adds to a growing list of setbacks for Cincinnati, a team that has had trouble fielding a consistent lineup in recent weeks. Injuries to key starters and relievers have tested the team’s depth, and with Callihan now a question mark, the Reds could look to make another roster move before their next series.

There may be an opportunity for other outfield prospects to get a shot, depending on the recovery timeline. Players like Rece Hinds, Jacob Hurtubise, or Michael Siani could be in line for a call-up if the team needs to fill Callihan’s roster spot.

Callihan’s defensive ability shines through despite injury

Despite the unfortunate outcome, Callihan’s effort on the play demonstrated the type of defensive intensity and commitment that teams value at the highest level. Willing to risk his body to make a play, the young left fielder showed his fearlessness and fielding instincts. While the ball came loose upon impact, the fact that he reached the fly ball in the first place impressed many observers.

If nothing else, the incident underscores the difficult nature of outfield defense in ballparks with aggressive corner angles like Atlanta’s Truist Park. For a rookie trying to make a name for himself, these moments can define early perceptions — and Callihan's grit did not go unnoticed.

Reactions from Reds and around MLB

As news of Callihan’s injury spread during the game, reactions poured in from fans and media across MLB. Reds teammates were visibly concerned as trainers assisted the outfielder off the field. On social media, fans praised Callihan’s hustle and expressed hope for a swift recovery.

Braves broadcaster Chip Caray described the play as "an incredibly gutsy effort from a young player trying to make an impossible catch." The sentiment was echoed by Reds color commentator Jeff Brantley, who noted, “That’s a player laying it all on the line.”

The Reds organization, known for giving young players a chance to develop at the major league level, has not indicated whether Callihan will be placed on the injured list. However, with the club in the midst of a long road trip, logistical decisions are expected soon.

Awaiting diagnosis

The coming days will be crucial for Tyler Callihan’s immediate future. A clean medical report could allow him to return quickly, while a more serious diagnosis could delay his rookie campaign indefinitely. Either way, the Reds are likely to proceed with caution, especially given Callihan’s potential as a long-term piece of their rebuilding strategy.

In the short term, fans and coaches alike will be hoping for the best — and appreciating the fire Callihan brought to a high-pressure moment on Monday night.